A Heroic Stand Against Overwhelming Odds

by W. THOMAS SMITH, JR. August 2, 2013

Maj. William P. "Bill" Collier's 54-hour pitched battle against massed wave-attacks from a determined, numerically superior enemy force may yet to have inspired a book or screenplay ("yet" mind you). But a growing number of military officers, various veterans' organizations, congressmen, senators, and at least one South Carolina governor believe the Columbia, S.C. man's epic defense of his 120-man position at Mo Duc in the Quang Ngai Province of South Vietnam, Sept. 16 - 18, 1972, was every bit as "desperate and dramatic" as Texas' last-stand at the Alamo or the British Army's defense of its isolated outpost at Rorke's Drift.

And a little-known group which meets at Columbia's Northeast Presbyterian Church (NEPC) is leading the charge to have Collier - today a retired U.S. Army colonel - awarded the nation's highest military decoration (for battlefield heroism) for this particular action.

Last week, the Veterans of Foreign Wars approved a national resolution "supporting congressional action to award the Medal of Honor" to Collier.

The VFW is not the first to endorse the effort. Two years ago, NEPC's Combat Veterans Support Group began the effort to have Collier's award of the Silver Star (for his heroic leadership in the battle) upgraded to the Medal of Honor.  An ambitious undertaking to be sure. But after learning of the two-day-six-hour fight, fellow combat-action veterans like retired U.S. Marine Col. Steve Vitali concluded that Collier's action warranted more.

william collier

"Collier's 120-man ARVN [Army of the Rep. of Vietnam] force defeated an NVA [North Vietnamese Army] force well over 2,000 men during a ferocious battle while twice repulsing NVA overruns of his position in hand-to-hand fighting," says Vitali, who served operationally in both Iraq and Afghanistan. "Collier repeatedly called artillery and air on his own position while continuously being exposed to withering fire in order to reposition his force and direct fire-support." 

Moreover, Collier "saved countless civilian lives by his decision not to fire on the refugee camp being held hostage by NVA from which they massed their assaults against his compound."

The stuff of heroic-legend some say - far beyond the ordinary - which is why the comparison to the Alamo where that garrison's commander, Lt. Col. William Barret Travis (also a South Carolinian) penned the words "Victory or Death" while defending the mission fortress in 1836.

Unlike the ill-fated Alamo where the defenders - including Travis, Kentucky knife-fighter Jim Bowie and Tennessee frontiersman and legislator Davy Crockett - all perished, Collier and his men were victorious. Thus the comparison to Rorke's Drift during Britain's war with the Zulu in 1879.

"Like Rorke's Drift, Major Collier assumed command of a small force at the start of the battle," says Vitali. "He was besieged and repeatedly assaulted by a vastly numerically superior enemy force attempting to wipe-out his command.  It was only through his inspirational leadership, extraordinary courage, and tactical expertise that his command was saved from annihilation while imposing on the enemy a reverberating defeat."

Former U.S. Army soldier and Vietnam veteran Bobby Farmer, who today serves as NEPC pastor of visitation, agrees. "He [Collier] kept his composure and stood his ground in what seemed to be a futile effort," says Farmer. "What's also important to note is that it took several years to get this story out of him, because he felt he was simply doing the job for which he had been trained."

Among those supporting Collier's being awarded the Medal of Honor are two Air Force forward air controllers - Captains Richard L. Polling and Joseph A. Personett - who, flying overhead, witnessed the intense fighting on the ground. Both men received the Air Force Cross, the nation's second-highest award (equal to the Distinguished Service Cross for the Army and the Navy Cross awarded to sailors and Marines), for providing air support to Collier's men for eight of the 54 hours Collier was slugging it out with the enemy on the ground.

Other endorsements include Maj. Gen. Robert Livingston (S.C.'s adjutant general), S.C. Gov. Nikki Haley, S.C. Attorney General Alan Wilson, U.S. Sen. Lindsey Graham, U.S. Sen. Tim Scott, Congressman Joe Wilson, Congressman Jeff Duncan, Congressman James Clyburn and others.

What became of the other members of Collier's 120 immortals? Only Collier and 21 South Vietnamese soldiers survived the battle. According to military.com, "Staff Sgt. Carroll Jackson, the only other American at the headquarters, was killed in the fighting." A Medal of Honor for Collier would be an award for all.


- Visit W. Thomas Smith Jr. at http://uswriter.com.

W. Thomas Smith Jr. - a former U.S. Marine rifleman - is a military analyst and partner with NATIONAL DEFENSE CONSULTANTS, LLC. Visit him at http://uswriter.com.

blog comments powered by Disqus

FSM Archives

10 year FSM Anniversary