China - Paper Tiger or Fire Breathing Dragon

by DARLENE CASELLA April 17, 2017

The meeting between President Trump and Premier Xi has Pundits scratching their heads about inscrutable outcomes.

Ancient treasures of China span over 5,000 years.   Two hundred years before Christ, emperors (descendants of powerful dragons) ruled centralized dynasties.    Mongol leader Kublai Khan led the Yuan Dynasty.    Philosopher Confucius lived over 3,000 years ago.   Ming Dynasty finished the Great Wall; and built the Forbidden City.    Marco Polo used The Silk Road.  Opium wars ended the Qin Dynasty; and in 1911 Sun Yat Sen led a revolution that ended dynastic rule.  China became a Republic.

More people live in China than any country in the world, with a population of 1.3 billion.  China is vast; bordering Afghanistan, Bhutan, Burma, India, Mongolia, Nepal, Pakistan, Tajikistan, and Vietnam; Hong Kong and Macau have autonomous borders. 

After the American Revolutionary War, The Empress of China sailed from the United States to open trade with Canton.  When Mao Zedong overthrew Chaing Kai-Shek, the American Embassy was moved to Taiwan in 1949. 

Mao Zedong's communist Red Army executed teachers, doctors, and educated people. Peasants were arrested, villages were destroyed and people relocated, books were burned and outlawed.  He died in 1976.

President Richard Nixon and National Security Advisor Henry Kissinger sought diplomacy to end the Vietnam War. Diplomatic relations with Mainland China did not exist.  Nixon hoped that China would pressure the North Vietnamese, when he made a historic visit to the People's Republic of China in 1972.  Nixon and Kissinger continued secret meetings with Chinese Premier Zhou Enlai. President Jimmy Carter recognized the Peoples Republic of China in 1979.

Deng Xiaoping became the leader after Mao.   Deng incorporated free enterprise, political, economic and social reforms, restored stability and economic growth.  The Tiananmen Square massacre in 1989 dwarfed his image, although his leadership was critical to China's revival.  China pivoted to a socialist economy, under Jiang Zemin.    Hu Jintao replaced Jiang until 2012.

Premier Xi Jinping's current leadership swept billions of investment dollars into China, with enormous foreign assets. China is a leader of global manufacturing.  China is the largest market for everything from cars to mobile phones.    This year Boeing built it's first overseas plant for 737's in China.  China will need 100 Boeing 737's each year. 

Chinese multi billion dollar companies build bridges, canals, buildings, and railroads around the world. One of the many Chinese operations found on every continent is the 300-mile railway between Nairobi and Mombasa.  The slow overnight train trip takes 12 hours.  Passengers are cautioned to stay inside, because in places the train is so slow that lions have pulled riders off.  The new ride will take 4 hours.

Currency manipulation charges, that China suppresses the Yuan to make exports more competitive, have been leveled at China since Mitt Romney first ran for president.

China's intentions and military power in Asia and the South China Sea cause tensions. China, Taiwan, Vietnam, Malaysia, Brunei, and the Philippines have competing claims to territory rights and to rights of oil and gas reserves. 

Navigation rights are also in dispute.  $5.3 trillion in trade passes through the South China Sea each year.  Many countries, including the United States, want the South China Sea to remain international water. 

The Department of Defense published that China is modernizing naval vessels, increasing submarines, and building aircraft carriers.   To expand outer boundaries China is constructing artificial islands in the South China Sea.

Stealing military secrets from the United States through cyber espionage has been undeterred for years.  China is developing aircraft, which rival the United States F-35 Fighter.  New classes of missiles, hypersonic glide vehicles, and surface to air missiles are being developed.   Advanced cruisers, and destroyers are in process.  Intercontinental ballistic missiles can carry nuclear payloads. It has the worlds the largest military ground force. 

Satellites for military and communications, meteorology, and electronic intelligence are assumed peaceful.   However antisatellite capabilities such as directed energy weapons, satellite jammers, and antisatellite missiles are in China's space assets.

In early April, the USS Carl Vinson Carrier Strike Group, with 7,500 personnel, was heading toward the South China Sea for exercises.  Reports regarding threats from Kim Jong Un diverted it towards North Korea, and the Carrier is coordinating operations with Japanese Naval Forces.

Administrations have different views of China.  President Obama appeared to see China as an amicable economic power with increasing military capabilities.  He did not confront China on its cyber espionage, claims to territories in disputed areas, or currency and trade manipulation. 

President Trump has a different tact, confronting Premier Xi about China's incursion into disputed territories in the South China Sea, and manipulative trade and currency practices.  Trump challenges China's attempts to dominate geography by intimidation.  

A meeting between Trump and Xi produced pliability regarding currency manipulation.   Reports are unconfirmed that if China will use their leverage in dealing with the nuclear saber rattling from Kim Jong Un; the charge of currency manipulation would be taken off the table.  Liberals portrait this is breaking a campaign promise.  Conservatives feel it is an artful deal for safety.

Is China a peaceful paper tiger or a dangerous fiery dragon? You and the world must decide, as President Trump looks behind the artfully painted mask. 

Help Us Grow with flower

Darlene Casella was, before her retirement, an English teacher, a stockbroker, and president/owner of a small corporation. She lives in La Quinta, California, and can be reached at

blog comments powered by Disqus

FSM Archives

10 year FSM Anniversary