Crony Capitalism is Failing; Let's Try the Real Thing

by DANIEL HANNAN January 6, 2012
 
'Opinion in good men is but knowledge in the making' stated John Milton (1608 – 1674) in the Areopagitica.
 
The past four years have seen governments throughout the West turn to a ghoulish corporatism, in which selected private companies are bailed out with public money. Understandably, people from across the political spectrum have reacted angrily. The Tea Partiers and the Occupiers are both protesting against the same thing, viz the rescue of large banks by taxpayers.
 
But whereas the Occupiers, in a slightly inchoate way, believe they are complaining about capitalism, free marketeers point out that, in a capitalist system, bad banks would have been allowed to collapse, their assets sold to more efficient competitors. Bondholders, shareholders and some depositors would have lost money, but taxpayers wouldn't have contributed a penny.
 
When we make that argument in full – as I did in a direct exchange with some Occupy LSX types recently (see here) – the typical response is 'Yeah, well that might be your theoretical capitalism, but we're dealing with the one that actually exists'.
 
This is a reasonable objection. We capitalists mustn't become like those student Trotskyists who were forever insisting that the USSR wasn't really communist, and that proper socialism had never been tried.
 
What, then, is genuine capitalism? Where can you find it? What changes do we need to make to the present system to get there? I was planning to write a lengthy blog about it, but then I discovered that Jesse Norman, the cerebral MP for Hereford, had got there first. His paper, The Case for Real Capitalism, is worth reading in full. Having worked in the City before becoming a philosophy don, he understands in practice as well as in theory where the system has gone wrong. And he proposes concrete steps to put it right, to make shareholders think of themselves as owners rather than investors, to incentivise saving and boost competition.
 
Above all, Jesse grasps that freedom is more than just an absence of rules: that it also implies responsibility and (in the absence of external restraints) self-control. Herein lies the difference between what Milton called 'liberty' and what he called 'licence'.  Jesse's paper is consciously conservative, yet underlines once more that, in practical terms, the differences between conservatives and libertarians can be deferred until the grave.
 
 
FamilySecurityMatters.org Contributor Daniel Hannan is a British writer and journalist. He has been Conservative MEP for South East England since 1999. He speaks French and Spanish and loves Europe, but believes that the EU is making its constituent nations poorer, less democratic and less free. He is the winner of the Bastiat Award for online journalism. 
 

Daniel Hannan is a British writer and journalist, and has been Conservative MEP for South East England since 1999. He speaks French and Spanish and loves Europe, but believes that the EU is making its constituent nations poorer, less democratic and less free. He is the winner of the Bastiat Award for online journalism.


blog comments powered by Disqus

10 year FSM Anniversary

Gay sports bar chain to Al Sharpton: 'You are the most disgusting human on this planet'; Update: Tweets deleted

December 21, 2014  00:08 AM

"There is not a place in hell dark enough for you."

What does Al Sharpton find 'reprehensible' about Saturday's cop killings? The answer is unbelievable

December 20, 2014  10:22 PM

"We do not believe that all police are bad." Good time to clear that up.

'Too little too late': Eric Holder calls for 'forging closer bonds' between police and communities they serve

December 20, 2014  09:14 PM

In the meantime, those "communities" fight for body cameras and against riot gear.

'Just got locked in a store': Mall of America fills up with protesters; Police threaten arrests [photos]; Updated

December 20, 2014  03:29 PM

"It will no longer be business as usual."

'RESPECT!' George W. Bush visits children's hospital as Santa (bonus: with security 'elf') [photo]

December 20, 2014  01:22 PM

Great gesture.

FSM Archives

More in PUBLICATIONS ( 1 OF 25 ARTICLES )