How home schooling threatens monopoly education

January 10, 2013

"What about home schooling? You know, it's not just for scary religious people any more." That's a line from Buffy The Vampire Slayer, and it should strike fear into the hearts, not of vampires, but of public-school administrators everywhere.

The fact is, Americans across the country -- but especially in large, urban school systems -- are voting with their feet and abandoning traditional public schools, to the point that teachers are facing layoffs. Some are going to charter schools, which are still public but are run more flexibly. Some are leaving for private schools. But many others are going another step beyond traditional education, and switching to online school or even pure home schooling.

And, as Buffy so accurately noted, it's not just "scary religious people." In fact, rather than scary, those religious people are looking more like trendsetters. A recent piece in The Atlantic told of purely secular parents' decision to take their kids out of New York public schools and home school instead:

"That first year, chatting with other homeschooling parents at soccer games, picnics, and after-church coffee hours, I found that our decision was far from unusual. Homeschooling has long been a philosophical choice for religious traditionalists and off-the-grid homesteaders, but for the parents we met - among them several actors, a jazz composer, a restaurateur, a TV chef, a Columbia University physical-plant supervisor, and a handful of college professors - it was a practical alternative to New York's notoriously inadequate education system."

New York's public school system is indeed notoriously inadequate. And, like most public school systems (or public systems of any kind), it's run more for the convenience of the staff and bureaucrats than for the benefit of parents or kids. Some kids do fine anyway, of course, and some parents aren't in a position to pursue alternatives. But for many parents, traditional schooling is no longer the automatic default choice.




blog comments powered by Disqus

'Standing on your heads'? NYT finds the 'upshot' in Hillary's plummeting poll numbers

October 13, 2015  03:21 PM

"Slosh some more lipstick on that pig."

The post ‘Standing on your heads’? NYT finds the ‘upshot’ in Hillary’s plummeting poll numbers appeared first on

Hillary Clinton responds to Donald Trump's plan to live-tweet tonight's #DemDebate

October 13, 2015  02:16 PM

Not so funny, Hillary.

The post Hillary Clinton responds to Donald Trump’s plan to live-tweet tonight’s #DemDebate appeared first on

War on cops: Rahm Emanuel blames 'fetal' police force for Chicago's rise in crime

October 13, 2015  10:01 AM

Blame the mayors, not the cops.

The post War on cops: Rahm Emanuel blames ‘fetal’ police force for Chicago’s rise in crime appeared first on

'Total amateur hour': AP reports on new vulnerabilities discovered on Hillary Clinton's email server

October 13, 2015  07:48 AM

This is internet security 101.

The post ‘Total amateur hour’: AP reports on new vulnerabilities discovered on Hillary Clinton’s email server appeared first on

Hillary Clinton joins union rally in Las Vegas in front of Trump International Hotel; Bill lays low

October 13, 2015  00:30 AM

Pro-union protesters had been promised a "special guest," though some were surprised to see Hillary Clinton and not Bernie Sanders.

The post Hillary Clinton joins union rally in Las Vegas in front of Trump International Hotel; Bill lays low appeared first on

10 year FSM Anniversary

FSM Archives