Obama’s EEOC: Employers Can’t Discriminate Against Felons

by SCOTT MCKAY August 17, 2010
You did, in fact, read that correctly.
HotAir.com has a story today on an Equal Employment Opportunities Commission directive posted to its website which advises employers that the results of criminal background checks can’t be used to exclude applicants because of the effects such practices may have on “protected groups.”
There is no Federal law that clearly prohibits an employer from asking about arrest and conviction records. However, using such records as an absolute measure to prevent an individual from being hired could limit the employment opportunities of some protected groups and thus cannot be used in this way.
Since an arrest alone does not necessarily mean that an applicant has committed a crime the employer should not assume that the applicant committed the offense. Instead, the employer should allow him or her the opportunity to explain the circumstances of the arrest(s) and should make a reasonable effort to determine whether the explanation is reliable.
Even if the employer believes that the applicant did engage in the conduct for which he or she was arrested that information should prevent him or her from employment only to the extent that it is evident that the applicant cannot be trusted to perform the duties of the position when
·         considering the nature of the job,
·         the nature and seriousness of the offense,
·         and the length of time since it occurred.
This is also true for a conviction.
HotAir’s Ed Morrissey notes that the idea a convicted felon can’t be excluded from a job on the basis of that conviction is absurd…
The hiring process involves a series of value judgments, with only a few objective measures.  For employers who conduct background checks, conviction records supply one of the few objective measures in the process.  If an employer has a choice between two equally qualified applicants and one has a conviction for fraud or theft, it would be absurd to tell the employer that the hiring decision cannot rest on that data.  And yet, that’s exactly what the EEOC argues in this “advice” on compliance with its regulations — which in this case the EEOC acknowledges doesn’t exist on this topic.  The EEOC is making a recommendation based on its own opinion rather than actual law.
Morrissey also asks the question whether – if true discrimination is so rare that EEOC has to attempt to forbid the use of criminal background checks as a disqualifier for potential employees - the EEOC still has a reason to soak up federal budget dollars. That’s a good question, in light of the fact that every state in the union has an equivalent anti-discrimination body. But the real issue here, which argues just as strongly for the elimination of the EEOC through de-funding when the GOP re-takes the House of Representatives in November, is the current administration’s out-of-control regulation of the private sector. Actions which would intimidate or encourage the hiring of criminals in the workplace create less-pleasant and less-productive environments for other employees, and distasteful regulations or “advice” such as this will make it even less attractive for employers to make new hires – or to make hires through interview processes open to all applicants outside of those employers might have  access to through contacts or networking.
No one will be helped by this policy. No one. Not even the applicants with criminal backgrounds who need a booming economy and a wide-open job market to find gainful employment.
FamilySecurityMatters.org Contributing Editor Scott McKay, a sales, marketing and business consultant, is the Publisher/Blogger at TheHayride.com, a news/commentary blog about Louisiana and national politics.

blog comments powered by Disqus

SHOCKER: 'Hamilton' star who rapped about Obamacare will fundraise for Hillary

June 25, 2016  11:15 PM

The cast of "Hamilton" will add an extra performance to help "dead broke" grandmother of two Hillary Clinton.

The post SHOCKER: ‘Hamilton’ star who rapped about Obamacare will fundraise for Hillary appeared first on twitchy.com.

Is Mia Love really snubbing Donald Trump by skipping the GOP convention?

June 25, 2016  10:08 PM

Mia Love's status as "rumored" VP pick came from a former Donald Trump staffer who admitted he wasn't part of any VP conversations.

The post Is Mia Love really snubbing Donald Trump by skipping the GOP convention? appeared first on twitchy.com.

'So many lies': Democrats might have to pass their own party platform to find out what's in it

June 25, 2016  06:21 PM

If the hot mess that is the GOP is getting you down, take comfort in knowing that the hammering out of the Democrat Party platform was pretty ugly.

The post ‘So many lies’: Democrats might have to pass their own party platform to find out what’s in it appeared first on twitchy.com.

'Rainbows on his mind': Times Square billboards announce America's first LGBTQ national monument

June 25, 2016  05:18 PM

The Stonewall Inn is now the centerpiece of the Stonewall National Monument and joins other "hallowed ground where history was written."

The post ‘Rainbows on his mind’: Times Square billboards announce America’s first LGBTQ national monument appeared first on twitchy.com.

Trump's golf course comments serve as inspiration for Caddyshack reboot

June 25, 2016  04:14 PM

"Czervik in Chief"?

The post Trump’s golf course comments serve as inspiration for Caddyshack reboot appeared first on twitchy.com.

FSM Archives

10 year FSM Anniversary