Supreme Court opens door to a new Obamacare challenge by the Christian college Liberty University

November 27, 2012

The Supreme Court has ordered a federal court of appeals to consider a Christian college's claim that its religious freedom is threatened by forced funding of abortion under the health care reform law.

"I am very pleased with the High Court's ruling," said Mat Staver, dean of Liberty University School of Law and founder of the nonprofit litigation group Liberty Counsel, which is representing the university.

The ruling "breathes new life into our challenge" to the Affordable Care Act, Staver said, asserting that mandated abortion funding under the law "collides with religious freedom and the rights of conscience."

On Nov. 26, the U.S. Supreme Court granted Liberty Counsel's petition to have its case reheard by the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond, Va., allowing the possibility for the Supreme Court to ultimately hear the case within the next year.

The lawsuit, initially filed in 2010 on behalf of Liberty University and two private individuals, challenged both the mandate requiring individuals to obtain health insurance and a regulation requiring employers to offer health insurance to their workers.

In addition to challenging the authority of Congress to pass the Affordable Care Act, Liberty University argued that the law's insurance exchange policies are unconstitutional because they "do not protect against payment for elective abortion coverage."

The university charges that the law includes forced funding of abortion despite religious objections and therefore violates the First Amendment's free exercise of religion protection and the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act.

As a Christian institution, Liberty University is morally opposed to abortion and does not cover it in its health care plan, the lawsuit explained.

It observed that under the health care reform law, states that provide for abortion coverage in health plans must segregate funds in order to ensure that no federal money received by a health care exchange can go towards abortions, with a few exceptions. This is in keeping with a law that prohibits the federal funding of most abortions.

The health care law has also raised considerable concern about freedom of religion due to its "preventive services mandate," which requires employers including religious schools, hospitals and charitable organizations to offer coverage of contraception, sterilization and early abortion drugs.    

FINISH


blog comments powered by Disqus

10 year FSM Anniversary

We'll give you one guess what Bill Nye Not-the-Climate-Scientist-Guy thinks caused the flooding in Houston

May 27, 2015  09:35 AM

"Bill Nye knows nothing about meteorology or climate."

Excessive CO2 emissions (and maybe lava) threaten endangered pink iguanas in the Galapagos

May 27, 2015  08:59 AM

Why does the planet keep trying to kill us?

Marie Harf promoted to senior advisor, will focus on negotiations with Iran

May 26, 2015  09:57 PM

These negotiations call for some high-level hashtag diplomacy.

Trigger warning: Patently offensive 'Choose Life' license plate could spark road rage

May 26, 2015  08:51 PM

New York State allows "Union Yes" plates, but "Choose Life" is considered politically divisive.

Familiar: Bernie Sanders kicks off campaign promising 'a political revolution to transform our country'

May 26, 2015  08:02 PM

But is it going to be a fundamental transformation?

FSM Archives

More in MUST READS ( 1 OF 25 ARTICLES )