Tea Party at a Crossroads

by SALENA ZITO December 21, 2012

Dispirited by congressional wrangling over the debt ceiling in 2011, Tea Party members‘ passions began to wane. Then other forces took hold to intensify the conservative movement‘s struggle to remain relevant, says Sen. Jim DeMint.

"They were discouraged by the performance of the Republicans (in budget talks) and they were intimidated by the Occupy Wall Street protest tactics, which gave rallies a bad name," DeMint, 61, a South Carolina Republican, told the Tribune-Review.

DeMint, in office since 2005, will resign in January to become president of The Heritage Foundation.

One of the Senate‘s most conservative members, he helped ignite the Tea Party movement. Now, DeMint said, he‘s not sure whether it will continue in its present form, become part of the Republican Party or attempt to become a third political party.

"They don‘t necessarily want to be Republicans," DeMint said. "If Republicans want to embrace the ideas of constitutional government and balanced budget, then they are fine with Republicans carrying the message and they will get behind them.

"But I don‘t think that most Tea Party people just want to get merged with the Republican Party. The jury is still out if ... you are going to see the emergence of a third party with a lot of libertarian themes."

Sam DeMarco, 54, of North Fayette, chairman of Western Pennsylvania Veterans and Patriots United, a Tea Party organization with 500 members, said he thinks the movement has reached a crossroads.

"We originally made the decision to not form a third party and stick with the Republicans because we understood that would almost guarantee that (Democratic candidates) would win," he said. "However, as the fiscal cliff negotiations continue and Washington Republicans are beginning to cave, that may become an option."

Finding its place

The Tea Party hasn‘t successfully transitioned from an outside pressure group to an inside influence group, said Lara Brown, a Villanova University political scientist.

"In Congress, they attempted this during the debt ceiling debate in the summer of 2011, but because of their uncompromising stance, the deal that eventually got done was not only not enough to satisfy their constituents but it was also so politically messy that the government‘s credit rating was downgraded," she said.

President Obama and House Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio, announced an agreement on July 31, and Obama signed the Budget Control Act of 2011 on Aug. 2. Days later, Standard & Poor‘s downgraded the government‘s credit rating. In September, the protest movement that came to be known as Occupy Wall Street established itself in New York City‘s financial district and within months spread to other cities.

From the movement‘s inception in January 2009, Washington politicos thought that the Tea Party could have a devastating effect on the 2012 election. They could not have been more wrong.

The Tea Party‘s force showed potential in the 2009 gubernatorial elections in New Jersey and Virginia, when Republicans Chris Christie and Bob McDonnell won in states that Obama won comfortably the year before. Tea Party-backed candidates then secured big wins in 2010 in the House, state legislatures and gubernatorial races. Yet by this year‘s election cycle, the movement had lost its mojo.

That‘s not surprising, Brown said.

"This is what happens to single-issue movements or third-party candidates," Brown said. "They typically last one or two cycles, and then they disappear."

Down, but not out

Evidence of the Tea Party‘s waning passion is no more apparent than in the case of Massachusetts Sen. Scott Brown. The Republican rode in on the initial wave of Tea Party movement in a January 2010 special election to fill the late Ted Kennedy‘s seat, but he lost this year to Democrat and consumer darling Elizabeth Warren.

Only four of 16 Senate candidates backed by Tea Party organizations won in November.

Tea Party-backed House candidates fared better - among them, Republican Keith Rothfus of Sewickley, who upset Rep. Mark Critz, D-Johnstown, and Rep. Michele Bachmann, R-Minn., founder of the Tea Party Caucus, who narrowly won re-election. But her Florida counterpart, Rep. Allen West, conceded a messy race to Democrat Patrick Murphy.

"It‘s clear the Tea Party still has salience in American politics, or at least in the Republican Party," said Sean Trende, senior elections analyst for RealClearPolitics. "It might be a faction - an unruly faction that‘s difficult to control - but it‘s still a faction at this point."

After helping to elect House members and state government representatives in 2011, many Tea Party groups lost an enemy. Their candidates had replaced the lawmakers who led to the movement‘s formation, by enacting programs such as the $700 billion Troubled Asset Relief Program to bail out banks, the $860 billion American Recovery Act to stimulate the economy, the GM restructuring plan and the health care bill.

Early in the 2012 GOP presidential primary, when 10 candidates jockeyed for position, the Tea Party became distracted from its fiscal goal, Villanova‘s Brown said. That caused its supporters to splinter and "they lost their power in all but the most conservative states" such as Texas, she said.

To Brown, it seems doubtful the movement can regroup under the Tea Party brand to influence elections.

"While fiscal conservatives and libertarians may again come together to protest the government‘s continued deficit spending and enormous debt," she said, "my guess is that they would need to call themselves something else and begin anew the process of organizing."


Contributing Editor Salena Zito is a political analyst, reporter and editorial page columnist at the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review. She can be reached at szito@tribweb.com.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Who's right: Donald Trump or Macy's?


mexico trump_macys_2015

Macy's has removed Donald Trump's products from their shelves because, while he stated that some of the Mexican people crossing our borders illegally are good people, some are murderers and rapists. While a true statement, it is not a "politically correct" statement, so Macy's has decided to pull his products from their shelves.

As a result of this, will you shop less - or not at all - in Macy's stores in the future?

10 year FSM Anniversary

Maddening: Mother, children seriously hurt after being hit by drunk driver who had been deported 6 times

July 07, 2015  00:17 AM

Will be deported for 7th time after serving sentence.

Illegal charged with murder; President has done 'everything within his power' to keep public safe

July 06, 2015  11:52 PM

Spokesman Josh Earnest blamed Republicans for blocking the president's efforts to catch criminals.

Sen. Bernie Sanders calls out Obama over unemployment figures, doubles president's claim

July 06, 2015  11:00 PM

The socialist running for the Democrat nomination says "real" unemployment is 10.5 percent.

Good question! Can Obama's 'better ideas' defeat the 'greatest security threat' America faces?

July 06, 2015  10:37 PM

Maybe if they're "super cool ideas"?

'I refuse to comply': Owner of bakery fined $135,000 not intimidated by accompanying gag order

July 06, 2015  09:35 PM

The Daily Signal explains to Slate that, yes, the owners of the bakery were placed under a gag order.

FSM Archives