The Two-State Solution is Dead. Long live what?
by TED BELMAN
January 20, 2014
The Two-State Solution is dead. All that remains is for the US to declare it so.
Palestinians leaders and Israeli leaders have made it clear.
In a speech on Jan 10/14, Palestinian Authority (PA) Chairman Mahmoud Abbas made it crystal clear that he would never abandon the "right of return", would never recognize Israel as a Jewish state and would never make a deal unless East Jerusalem was given to the Palestinians as their capital, all of which cross Israel's red lines.
When the latest "peace process was getting started, Israeli leaders kept referring to Abbas as a moderate, contrary to the truth, and even referred to him as a partner in peace, also not the truth. No more.
Upon Israel's release of the third batch of murderers in December and in response to the leaders of the PA celebrating them as heroes, PM Netanyahu said:
"Murderers are not heroes. [..] This is no way to educate toward peace. This is no way to make peace. Peace can be achieved only when the education toward incitement and toward the destruction of Israel is stopped. There will be peace only if our security and settlement interests are ensured. Peace will be established only if we could defend ourselves, by ourselves, against any threat."
In the past week, Netanyahu, Yaalon and Bennett all criticized Abbas.
Netanyahu told VP Biden that recent comments by Abbas were proof that he does not want peace.
Min of Defense Boogie Yaalon said, Mahmoud Abbas "lives on our sword," "Once we leave Judea and Samaria, he is finished. In fact, throughout the recent months, there is no negotiation between us and the Palestinians - but rather, between us and the Americans. The only thing that can ‘save' us is that John Kerry will get a Nobel peace prize and leave us alone." and "I live and breathe the conflict with the Palestinians, I know what they think, what they want and what they really mean," he went on. "The American security plan that was presented to us is not worth the paper it was written on."
Economy Minister Naftali Bennett denounced Abbas as "no different than Yasser Arafat,"
The fact that Yaalon was forced to apologize does not invalidate the truth of his remarks.
No doubt that Kerry is now looking for an exit strategy from his doomed efforts to force Israel to make concessions.
If not the Two-State Solution, then what?
Wm Galston writing in The New Republic on June 2011, said: "Benjamin Netanyahu offers no viable alternative to the status quo, and the opposition offers no viable alternative to Netanyahu. [..] The majority of Israelis actually seem comfortable to the point of complacency with today's de facto truce and limited Palestinian autonomy."
He was right. Netanyahu, Yaalon and many Israelis, though they prefer the Two State Solution on their terms, in its absence, are quite comfortable with maintaining the status quo.
But not everyone embraces the status quo. They fear Israel's further isolation and deligitimation. They are clamouring to be pro-active rather than passive or defensive.
They all want to annex Judea and Samaria (West Bank) but differ on what to do with the Arabs that live there.
Deputy Minister of Transportation, MK Tzipi Hotovely recently said:
"The goal is for Judea and Samaria to be under Israeli sovereignty. It is ours and it was acquired legally in a bloody, defensive war. We must now implement the vision of the Greater Land of Israel and begin to apply sovereignty in all of the territory. This is the vision reflecting belief in the holy precept that the Land of Israel is ours and we have no right to revoke this precept. It is fidelity to the ideology of the Right and the religious public, which believes that this is our land."
"We must begin a gradual process of 25 years under the heading of ‘annexation-naturalization'."
" We must bear in mind that this is a hostile entity and it is impossible to turn them into citizens overnight."
Caroline Glick recently published her latest book, ‘The Israeli solution: A One State Plan for Peace in the Middle East' arguing that whereas in Israel, the conversation has begun about alternatives to the ‘Two-State' model, no such conversation is taking place in America. Instead American policy beginning with Nixon was and is to appease the PLO, now PA, at Israel's expense.
"The only thing that should interest us is that Judea and Samaria is Israel," she says and notes that even though providing the Palestinians with permanent residency and the right to apply for citizenship is not a perfect solution and will damage Israel on certain levels, "it is absolutely clear that it is better than establishing a Palestinian state. Such a state would be the ruin of Israel."
Prof Martin Sherman, while totally supporting the annexation of Judea and Samaria, warns Glick and Hotovely, to "look before you leap" for reasons he makes clear. He is adamantly against offering citizenship.
"Topping the list of bad ideas is the notion that, given the proven infeasibility of the two-state paradigm, Israel should extend its sovereignty over the entire area of Judea-Samaria and offer "immediate permanent residency to all its [Arab] Palestinian residents, as well as the right to apply for citizenship." This is an approach so fraught with manifest disaster that it pains me that someone of the caliber of Caroline B. Glick, for whom I have the utmost regard and with whom I am seldom in disagreement, has chosen to advocate it.
"An almost childlike naiveté is required to entertain the belief that Israel could sustain itself as a Jewish nation-state with a massive Muslim minority of almost 40% - as the societal havoc that far smaller proportions have wrought in Europe indicate."
Instead, he argues for a "humanitarian solution" which envisages voluntary Arab emigration induced by generous compensation.
Glick rejects this and the Jordan Option as "irrelevant ideas that no one will accept, especially the Palestinians themselves."
But were Sherman's idea be adopted by the US and the EU, the conflict would be fully and finally solved in a decade.
Kerry for his part has resorted to threatening Israel with dire consequences should she not capitulate. In a November interview in Israel he said: "If we do not resolve the issues between Palestinians and Israelis, if we do not find a way to find peace, there will be an increasing isolation of Israel, there will be an increasing campaign of delegitimization of Israel that's been taking place on an international basis," In fact Governmental sources report that US Secretary of State John Kerry is behind the European boycott threats on Israeli products and companies operating in Judea, Samaria, eastern Jerusalem and the Golan Heights.
At the Saban Conference in November, he said "Force cannot defeat or defuse the demographic time bomb."
What Demographic Bomb
While the left, the EU and the USA continue to threaten Israel with claims that Israel is losing the demographic war, the opposite is the truth. Amb (ret) Yoram Ettinger has been studying the demographics in Israel for a decade and has often written that the demographic trend supports Israel now in the foreseeable future. According to him, Jews outnumber Arabs from the river to the sea, excluding Gaza, by a 2:1 majority and the numbers will only get better.
But the Two-State Solution carries with it a real demographic bomb. If a Palestinian state was created, Lebanon, Syria and Jordan would demand that the descendants of the original refugees now living in their countries, numbering now over 4 million, be returned to Palestine. If the PA gives up the "right of return", and most of these "refugees" were to return to Palestine, both Palestine and Israel would be greatly destabilized. So much so, as to require no return to Palestine either.
"I brief the members of the House of Representatives and the Senate several times every year. Each time I present this plan on Capitol Hill, the response borders on euphoria. In the United States, just as in Israel, there are millions of people who understand that the ‘Two-State' solution is a disaster. They are just waiting for someone to tell them that they can abandon it. My book gives them, and the Israeli public as well, the alternative that they are waiting for."
Let's hope they adopt it.
Ted Belman practised law in Toronto and started an international business before making aliya in 2009. He currently lives in Jerusalem. He is one of the founders of the pro-Israel blog, Israpundit, and has been its editor/publisher for 15 years.