Exclusive: Clinton-Appointed Judge Backs Off Sanctions on Obama Eligibility Suit

On March 25th, Clinton-appointed Judge James Robertson (U.S. District Court), after having threatened to impose financial sanctions on John D. Hemenway for having enjoined the Berg lawsuit to force President Obama to release his birth records to prove his citizenship, backed down. Instead of financial penalties, the Judge issued a reprimand tinged with flippancy.  
Judge Robertson reconsidered his previous sanctions threat, possibly fearing monetary sanctions might spark a backlash and give a boost to the grassroots effort to force Mr. Obama to relinquish his records for public scrutiny. While the Judge gives passing tribute to Hemenway's long career of public service, "Mr. Hemenway is 82 years old and takes considerable and justified pride in his patriotic public service and his status as a Rhodes Scholar" he errs in one key respect, alleging that Hemenway is "unlikely to repeat the conduct that gave rise to this proceeding, and in his case the permissible alternative sanction of a reprimand will be sufficient." Reprimand aside, Hemenway will continue to seek the truth about Obama's birthplace and citizenship, as will other patriotic citizens who believe no President and no future Presidential candidate should be allowed to conceal documents that would prove that he or she is legally qualified to serve.
The Judge did concede that others "similarly situated" are "unlikely to be deterred, except by a penalty that would be unreasonable to impose on Mr. Hemenway alone." But curiously, the Judge previously only threatened Hemenway with financial sanctions, not Philip Berg, Hillary Clinton's ally, or the other lawyer involved in the case, Lawrence Joyce from Arizona
The Judge errs in another respect, saying: "Many people, perhaps as many as a couple of dozen, feel deeply about this issue, a strong indication that this Judge feels he can dismiss the legal merits of the issue by pretending that there is no public interest at stake.” He must be unaware that an AOL poll, albeit admittedly unscientific, found that a majority of Americans believe Mr. Obama should release his records to determine his eligibility; that more than 345,000 U.S. citizens have signed an online petition demanding Obama's birth records be released; and that many more are blogging, calling, and writing Congressional offices to ask their Members of Congress to sign onto Congressman Bill Posey's bill.
The Posey legislation would require future candidates for President to be vetted for eligibility, an admission that the last national election's screening process for candidates was substandard. Ironically, it was this very process of blogging and Twittering that the Judge earlier invoked as having already settled the eligibility issue – therefore, based on this flawed rationale, there was no need for his own court to weigh in, review evidence and relevant documents to determine whether Mr. Obama is a "natural born" citizen.   
This is a Judge who clearly is letting his skewed perception of public sentiment guide his judicial rulings. It would clearly have been judicially expedient, saving the taxpayers time and money, given the number of eligibility lawsuits filed across the country, simply to direct President Obama to produce an actual birth (or "vault") certificate and not a COLB (Certification of Live Birth and one that lacks a doctor's signature or hospital name) that has been given to others not born on the island of Hawaii.
According to the Washington Times, the Judge claimed he suffered "emotional distress" after receiving a letter from an elderly gentleman, Philip Merrell, a resident of Washington, D.C., who vented outrage at the Judge for his threat to levy sanctions on Hemenway for petitioning the court. The Judge's emotional distress resulted in the dispatch of two armed federal marshals who paid a visit to the Merrell home to inquire as to whether the gentleman knew Hemenway, purportedly at the judge's prompting. For the record, no Hemenway had ever heard of Mr. Merrell until the marshals' visit was exposed by the Washington Times, but we certainly understand his consternation about anyone aspiring to become President while keeping birth, academic and passport records under lock and key, while continuing to tout publicly the "openness" of his Administration. We also share Mr. Merrell's indignation that a judge whose principal duty is to uphold the law instead engages in judicial hocus pocus and obfuscation, rather than address in his courtroom the Constitutional requirement for the Presidency to be a "natural born citizen" as laid out in Article II, Section 1.    
FamilySecurityMatters.org Contributing Editor Margaret Hemenway is the daughter-in-law of John D. Hemenway and spent 15 years in the Congress, both House and Senate, and five years as a White House appointee at DoD and NASA.  

blog comments powered by Disqus

Donald Trump wants 'human garbage' Edward Snowden brought back for trial

April 19, 2014  10:49 PM

Russian President Vladimir Putin seems a little preoccupied these days, but maybe President Obama can bring it up during one of their phone calls. @realDonaldTrump yes, let's March into Russia and snag him. No world superpower would care!— Matthew Dávila (@SodaPop6548) April 18, 2014 @realDonaldTrump @wikileaks well… I don´t think they´re gonna release him just […]

'People really need this much hand-holding?': Government reminds citizens to pay their premiums

April 19, 2014  06:52 PM

Now that Obamacare’s open enrollment period has passed, there’s just one other tiny detail nagging at those millions of new sign-ups — paying their premiums. The administration’s being awfully quiet about how many enrollees have actually paid their first premium, but they have sent out a subtle reminder via Twitter that Obamacare isn’t free after all. If […]

Today in the War on Women: OFA slaughters self-awareness in a single email [pic]

April 19, 2014  02:40 PM

Party of Logic.

Obama admin: No worries, Obamacare is doing fine, but we have one little request [pic]

April 19, 2014  10:24 AM

Out: Get covered. In: You guys are gonna pay, right?

President Clinton warned: 'The right wing has seized upon the internet'

April 18, 2014  08:05 PM

In the mid-’90s, President Bill Clinton received a report about the Internet, or as the report puts it, the “Communication Stream of Conspiracy Commerce.” In particular, the report warns of the growing influence of the GOP online: The internet has become one of the major and most dynamic modes of communication. The internet can link people, groups and […]

FSM Archives