HOME :: PUBLICATIONS :: Homeland Security That Is Not So Slick, by JAMES JAY CARAFANO, PHD

Homeland Security That Is Not So Slick

by JAMES JAY CARAFANO, PHD May 26, 2010
At 8:46 a.m. on September 11, 2001, American Airlines Flight 11 crashed into North Tower. Seventeen minutes later, United Airlines Flight 175 hit the South Tower.
 
The response was massive and nearly instantaneous. Within minutes, would-be rescuers flooded the site of the tragedy. Most did not wear uniforms.
 
In addition to police, fire and EMT services, construction workers flocked to the scene. And there was plenty of work for all. During the initial round-the-clock search and cleanup period, Ground Zero kept about 10,000 skilled support personnel (heavy equipment operators, truck drivers, iron workers, carpenters and laborers) busy each day.
 
Like many heroic efforts, it was foolhardy as well. Virtually nothing had been done to prepare these responders to respond safely. Many lacked basic personal protective equipment such as work boots, masks and gloves. The first ones in had no safety briefings, much less formal training.
 
"I saw first-hand the inadequacies of the training for skilled support," wrote Bruce Lippy, an investigator on the scene. "Subsequent studies by Mount Sinai Medical Center have indicated that over half of the 2,500 workers they have screened as of November 25, 2002 are still suffering respiratory symptoms. This indicates a real need for better training of these worker populations: We can give them more than the three-hour training we provided three months after the attack."
 
Ultimately, the lack of preparation turned thousands of 9/11 responders into 9/11 victims. In March, New York City agreed to pay over $657 million to more than 10,000 responders for injuries and illnesses suffered as a result of their work at Ground Zero.
 
But have officials learned the painful lesson of this experience? Probably not. Just look at what's happening along the Gulf Coast.
 
After the worst oil spill in U.S. history, Gulf residents rushed to volunteer their help with the cleanup. Many area fishermen, armed with little more than booms and their boats, set sail to help contain the spill. But few left port with anything approaching adequate training and protective equipment.
 
There is some indication that, over the past few weeks, responders were getting better training and equipment. Let's hope it's not too little, too late. After the cleanup of the 1989 Exxon Valdez oil spill, responders reported suffering maladies ranging from chronic respiratory illnesses to cancer.
 
Washington bears part of the blame. After 9/11, Lippy and Kerry Murray wrote a report for the National Institutes of Health arguing that the United States needed a disaster response system able to do more than merely mobilize millions of private-sector construction workers in response to a catastrophe. It needed to be able to ensure them a reasonable level of safety as well.
 
Almost a decade later, virtually nothing has been done.
 
Instead, Congress and the Department of Homeland Security have gone haring down almost every homeland security-related rabbit trail out there, giving short shrift to their most important job: preventing and preparing an effective response to potentially catastrophic disasters.
 
Congress still toys with homeland security, dispersing oversight of the department across an unbelievable 108 committees, subcommittees and commissions.
 
The department fritters away resources responding to an ever-increasing number of state "emergency calls." By thus "nationalizing" run-of-the-mill disaster response, DHS each year devotes less time and fewer resources preparing for the really big disasters.
 
That's why, when something really big like the Gulf oil spill comes along, the department is caught flat-footed. And so we have Coast Guard Rear Adm. Peter Neffenger from the Department of Homeland Security admitting to Congress, "Clearly this is beyond what we anticipated."
 
FamilySecurityMatters.org Contributing Editor James Jay Carafano, Ph.D., is a leading expert in defense affaires, intelligence, military operations and strategy, and homeland security at the Heritage Foundation.

James Carafano is a leading expert in defense affairs, intelligence, military operations and strategy, and homeland security at The Heritage Foundation. He was an Assistant Professor at the U.S. Military Academy in West Point, N.Y., and fleet professor at the U.S. Naval War College. Carafano is the author of several military history books and studies. Carafano also is the coauthor of Winning the Long War: Lessons from the Cold War for Defeating Terrorism and Preserving Freedom; coauthor of the text book, Homeland Security published by McGraw-Hill; and the principal author of Emergency Responders: Drastically Underfunded, Dangerously Unprepared. He has testified before the U.S. Congress and has provided commentary for ABC, BBC, CBS, CNBC, CNN, C-SPAN, Fox News, MSNBC, NBC, SkyNews, PBS, National Public Radio, the History Channel, Voice of America, Al Jazeera, Telemundo, Al Arabiya and Australian, Austrian, Canadian, French, Greek, Hong Kong, Irish, Japanese, Portuguese, and Spanish television. His editorials have appeared in newspapers nationwide including The Baltimore Sun, The Boston Globe, The New York Post, Philadelphia Inquirer, USA Today and The Washington Times. Carafano is a member of the National Academy's Board on Army Science and Technology, the Department of the Army Historical Advisory Committee, and is a Senior Fellow at the George Washington University's Homeland Security Policy Institute.

Archives Pre-May 8, 2008: Please click here


blog comments powered by Disqus

The #twittergulag saga continues: @gopfirecracker suspended, others still trapped

May 21, 2012  11:54 PM

#freegopfirecracker #freegopfirecracker #freegopfirecracker #freegopfirecracker— Dale Holt (@DaleHolt8) May 22, 2012 Come on conservatives! Everyone rallied around @ChrisLoesch when he was suspended! Now its @gopfirecracker so stand up! #freegopfirecracker— Schmoop (@RGSchmoop) May 22, 2012 Hey @twitter and @support – #FreeGOPfirecracker's account has been suspended. Please fix this mishap. Thank you.— Gabriella Hoffman (@Gabby_Hoffman) May 22, 2012 [...]

Cory Booker tweets #IStandWithObama; Hashtag hijackers flood the zone

May 21, 2012  11:39 PM

Newark, N.J., Mayor Cory Booker, the Democrat who defended Bain from the Obama campaign's attacks yesterday morning, has been backpedaling more furiously than a clown on a high wire. Tonight, in an effort to mollify his critics on the Left, he posted four tweets that included the hashtag #IStandWithObama. Conservatives immediately took over the #IStandWithObama hashtag to mock President Obama, and within an hour it became a trending topic.

Cory Booker tries to clear up his position on Bain attacks

May 21, 2012  10:25 PM

Cory Booker continued his quest to run screaming away from the apparently too candid comments he made on Meet the Press on Sunday. Despite attempts earlier today to #FreeCoryBooker from those trying to force him to apologize Booker went on the Rachel Maddow show to do everything he could to walk back what he said. Que the mockery.

Obama's 'When you're president' picture spawns hashtag

May 21, 2012  09:59 PM

"When you're president, as opposed to the head of a private equity firm, then your job is not simply to maximize profits. Your job is to figure out how everybody in the country has a fair shot." -Barack Obama Cue #WhenYouArePresident

Obama takes anti-Romney rant to Twitter

May 21, 2012  09:49 PM

It started off this morning with a video of a woman named Valerie from Indiana posted by Barack Obama’s official Twitter account. 12 hours, 12 tweets and a failed hashtag later, Obama’s reelection team took the day to tweet ongoing misinformation about Mitt Romney’s record in the private sector, specifically Bain Capital’s work with the [...]

FSM Archives

  FSM Archive   Search Must Reads
More in PUBLICATIONS ( 1 OF 25 ARTICLES )