September 7, 2010
Administration’s Minimal NatSec Plans
Presidential Policy: Does It Make the Grade?, James Jay Carafano, PhD

The President’s address from the Oval Office was without question the biggest foreign policy and national security news from the Administration last week. The speech marking the “end” of the Iraq War was, by accounts from the Right and the Left a hodge-podge of political messaging and presidential-sounding rhetoric that failed to impress. Maureen Dowd confined her pithy comments to trashing the president’s interior decorator.
On the three top national security issues he mentioned—Iraq, Afghanistan, and defense—the President said almost nothing new of substance to suggest how he will handle these issues in the future. President Obama’s speech, ostensibly focused on Iraq, actually gave short shrift to the war in Iraq and failed to articulate a vision of Iraq’s future, his own Iraq policy, or America’s role in the world.
In large measure the speech was predictable, reflecting the tenets of what clearly can be called the “Obama Doctrine.” The signature elements of this doctrine appear to be: (1) Downplaying American sovereignty: The Administration is pursuing an ambitious agenda on international treaties; (2) Soft-pedaling American power: The belief that the United States over-utilized hard power in Iraq and Afghanistan has shaken President Obama’s confidence in the application of hard power at all. Instead, the President intends to use soft power so as to appear more equal at the negotiating table; (3) A more restrained America: President Obama has made no secret of his ambivalence toward American military power; and (4) A more humble America: Since his first month in office, President Obama has embarked on a whirlwind Apology Tour casting himself as the redemptive vessel for the entirety of America’s past sins.
In the end it was another week when the White House did little to distinguish itself in its efforts to keep the nation free, safe, and secure. The grade for the week has to be “D” for not too darn good.