Does the Bin Laden Decapitated Snake Still Have Life?

by DR. LAINA FARHAT-HOLZMAN May 4, 2011
 
Was the killing of Osama Bin Laden “justice,” as President Obama has said, or was it “vengeance,” as both critics and admirers claim? Justice, technically, could have been served by putting that monster on trial-or a succession of trials everywhere he had ordered mass murders (Kenya, Yemen, Bali, Mumbai, London, Spain, and the United States).  Taking him out, the way we did, as he tried to use women and children as human shields, could be said to be vengeance, but I don't think it was.  Justice is not just a trial of one's peers; in addition, it is seeing to it that a criminal does not get away with it.  We want to live in a fair, just world, not an endless cycle of vengeance.

If we want to remember what a vengeance world is like, just take a look at tribal life-particularly Muslim tribal life around the world-where the key value is “honor,” the preservation of which demands blood settlement. In our own past, even Western civilization has gone through phases of “honor” and revenge for “insult.” Gentlemen used to duel when offended by a remark or action, taking the duel to the death of one of the duelers. This ended in the 19th century.

But it is interesting to see where in our own civilization deadly honor codes and vengeance were most valued: Spain and Sicily, both of which were long under Muslim rule. They picked up this value from Arab vengeance codes-not only demanding the death of offending men, but also of women who “dishonored” their menfolk by real or imagined sexual infidelity. 

We need to keep separate the pleasure we all take vicariously in movies and plays in which “getting even” delights us-and actually having a society based on this sort of thing.  We really do not have such a society, and the removal of Osama Bin Laden had more to do with justice than vengeance.  It also had practical value. The symbolism of his survival for so many years after his criminal acts was an affront to us-and to those modern states that try to operate by rule of law.

What is Bin Laden's legacy? He created a mafia based on an extremely primitive interpretation of Islam, an interpretation that demanded dictatorial control over all Muslims.  As his movement and his franchises rampaged throughout the world, they left behind a trail of violence, blood, and indifference to a body count that included far more Muslims than non-Muslims. When suicide bombers detonated themselves in markets filled with women and children, their handlers considered it justified because women should be at home, not out shopping.  When weddings and funerals were targeted by bombers, that's fine because they were not praying at the mosque.  When mosques were blown up, that was fine because they belonged to Muslim sects other than Al Qaeda's. This has not sat well with Muslims around the world, who are finally ready to condemn this movement.

Osama Bin Laden is dead, his body in the Indian Ocean, and there will never be a shrine to his burial place for fools to attend. He is gone. But Militant Islam is still alive, and for all the talk about the “Arab Spring” and all the wonderful young people who want “freedom and dignity,” it is not going to happen.

How can Egypt have “freedom and dignity” when in the midst of their demonstrations, a mob of men savagely targeted, raped, and beat an American woman journalist, attempting to tear her limb from limb, because they thought she was a Jew (Zionist spy)? What kind of “Power to the People” can Egypt have when a vast majority polled believe that there should be death for blasphemy (“insulting” the Prophet or Islam)?

Until the ignorance, religious bigotry, and vengeance codes become unacceptable to Egyptians, they will not have a modern, thriving country, nor will any other Muslim state in the Arab world. Bin Laden is dead, but the poisonous culture that created him is still alive for some time to come.  But this too will come to an end.
 
 
FamilySecurityMatters.org Contributing Editor Dr. Laina Farhat-Holzman is an historian, lecturer, and author who also writes for the Santa Cruz Sentinel. You may contact her at Lfarhat102@aol.com or http://www.globalthink.net/. Her latest book is:HOW DO YOU KNOW THAT? A Guide to Critical Thinking about Global Issues,” which will be reviewed on FSM next week.
 


FamilySecurityMatters.org
Contributing Editor Dr. Laina Farhat-Holzman is a historian, lecturer, and author of How Do You Know That? You may contact her at Lfarhat102@aol.com or www.globalthink.net.


blog comments powered by Disqus

The 15 best liberal fairy tales

May 22, 2012  09:03 PM

#LiberalFairyTales are all the absurd stories that liberals tell themselves and, sadly, everybody else. Here are the absolute best ones twitterers ever did tweet.

Ky. primary has Barack Obama doing battle with a phantom; Let the mockage begin!

May 22, 2012  07:50 PM

Vote-counting for the Kentucky primary is underway, and Obama is leading among preferred Democratic presidential candidates. But ah, ah, ah … not so fast there, Barack. Looks like not everything’s comin’ up roses in the Bluegrass State. ONE FOR UNDECIDED: Bath County, Kentucky Democrats take "Undecided" over President Obama by 725-715 votes— Jamie Dupree (@jamiedupree) [...]

War on women: S.C. AFL-CIO President violently smashing Nikki Haley effigy, no regrets; Update: I stand with Haley

May 22, 2012  04:29 PM

The South Carolina AFL-CIO president is on video beating an effigy of Governor Nikki Haley with a bat. War on women, indeed, and it comes from the Left as always. To Leftist thugs and union goons, she was asking for it, you see. That "uppity" woman won't keep her mouth shut and all. Scratch a Leftist and you will find not only a misogynist, but a racist.

Media still covering for no Biden access for press, blame Romney

May 22, 2012  03:39 PM

Media bias alert! RT @zekejmiller: Worth noting, given Romney flap last week, press not given rope-line access to Biden event here in NH— Sarah Huisenga (@SarahH_CBSNJ) May 22, 2012 Um. After the “Romney flap?” You mean the “flap” that the media breathlessly and endlessly reported all while ignoring the fact that reporters were shooed off [...]

Biden, Obama's bane, on Bain: ‘Making money is their job and legitimate'; Update: Also insults plumbers

May 22, 2012  03:08 PM

I'll see your Cory Booker and raise you a Joe Biden.— David Freddoso (@freddoso) May 22, 2012 Rut roh! Shall we add him to “hostage watch?“ Biden: When Bain companies failed, it cost taxpayers money in unemployment insurance, pension costs.— Mike Memoli (@mikememoli) May 22, 2012 Uh. When they are “too big to fail” and [...]

FSM Archives

More in PUBLICATIONS ( 1 OF 25 ARTICLES )