IDShield Alternatives Reviewed: Boost Your Identity Security

Last Updated on January 8, 2024

There are many products in the market designed to help you protect and recover from identity theft. Among those, I’ll be reviewing IDShield and how it compares to competitors.

I must say, however, that ultimately, when it comes down to the best of all identity theft protection services out there, Aura is the best in the market. 

Out of all the platforms I’ve tested, including IDShield, Aura found the most alerts – letting me know where I needed to focus to keep my identity safe. 

But this is a review of how IDShield compares to the competitors, and it’s alternatives. Let’s dive in!

Best IDShield Alternatives in 2024

Choose Aura If…

Why You Should Get Aura:

  • You want exceptional threat monitoring & alerts.
  • You’re keen on getting the maximum in theft insurance on Aura’s family plan.
  • You’d like efficient, knowledgeable 24/7/365 US-basedcustomer care.
  • You want the most value for your moneyfor the mostprotection.
You don’t need more than $1 million in identity theft insurance.
Identity theft protection isn’t your top priority, but reputation management is.
Just a few alerts and limited monitoring is all you’re interested in.
You can live with limited customer service support.

Choose Identity Guard If…

You want fantastic monitoring and alerts.
$1 million in theft insurance is enough for you.
You don’t mind paying a higher price compared to other services.
Basic protection is enough for you.

Choose Identity Force If…

You don’t care that much about having limited customer service support.
You don’t need or want 401(k) monitoring and home title monitoring.
$1 million theft insurance is more than enough.
You want a basic service with solid threat and credit monitoring and efficient resolution.

Top IDShield Competitors Features Compared

IDShield vs. Aura

Aura was designed by the same company behind Identity Guard as a kind of successor service and offers most of the same features and technology driving it, but with a few extras and a better pricing structure. 

It has exceptionally accurate monitoring and delivers alerts quickly (which is what you want if your identity is compromised). Its pricing is a lot more affordable for all that you get, compared to any other service. And, here is the cherry on top: It offers you a few extra features, such as a VPN, antivirus, and parental controls.

What I like about Aura is that no matter which plan you choose, at every tier you get the same level and range of services. That goes for the amount of theft insurance per adult member too  – $1 million per adult, or $5 million with the family plan. 

Aura vs. IDShield: Head-to-Head Comparison

Aura
IDShield
Overall Score
5/5
3.5/5
Monitoring & Alerts
Aura found 35 in total and 15 unique dark web alerts, the maximum in our test
IDShield found 24 alerts in total, and eight unique dark web alerts
Threat Resolution
White Glove support standard on all plans
Excellent customer service
Theft Insurance Per Adult
  • $5 million Theft Insurance total on the Family plan with 5 adults
  • $1 million per adult on all plans
$1 million total theft insurance on all plans
Customer Support
Aura offers US-based 24/7/365 support
US-based 24/7 support
Additional Services
  • VPN
  • Antivirus
  • Parental Controls
  • Password Manager
  • VPN
  • Antivirus software (with 15 device licenses)
  • Parental Controls
  • Reputation management tool
Cost
Aura offers an incredibly low price and value for your money
More expensive than Aura with less protection
Renewal Price Increased After 1st Year?
No. You lock in the price for life
No
Promo Code

Aura Pros

Aura’s list of what it monitors is very comprehensive and includes 401(k), investment, vehicle and home title monitoring. These are rarely covered by other services, and when they are, it’s at a premium. 

The number of alerts Aura provides exceeds every other service in our tests.

Aura’s pricing is a major pro as well, when you consider what you get for your hard-earned money. 

Unlike other services out there, the price you pay for the first year is the price you’ll pay for life! No increases – ever! 

Another pro is the amount of theft insurance you get – $1 million per adult (up to $5 million if you have a family with adult kids and/or in-laws or parents).This far outweighs anything else on the market.

Aura Cons

Frankly, it’s hard to find anything to complain about. 

One con, however, is that it would be a better identity theft protection service if it covered kids living elsewhere. Currently, children in the Family plan need to live under the same roof as the plan’s primary member, which affects divorced parents or parents with youngsters away at college.

Other than that, their dashboard needs some redesigning too. It’s not particularly user-friendly. And, their VPN could be beefed up (it is more like a DNS server masker and not very robust). 

Similarly, the antivirus isn’t anything to write home about.

Aura Pricing, Free Trial, and Promo Codes

Plan Type
Annual Billing
Monthly Billing
Individual
$144 /year
$15 /month
Couple (2 Adults)
$264 /year
$29 /month
Family (5 Adults, Unlimited Children)
$444 /year
$50 /month

Identity Guard

Identity Guard is a major player in identity theft protection, and it has been around for almost 20 years. 

It is one of the most popular identity theft protection services on the market and trusted by over 43 million subscribers. It’s the service that Aura was based on, offering much the same with regard to accuracy in monitoring and providing quick alerts.

The only problem is Identity Guard’s really good features are only covered in the Ultra plan, which is quite expensive. 

Identity Guard vs. IDShield: Head-to-Head Comparison

Identity Guard
IDShield
Overall Score
4.5/5
3.5/5
Monitoring & Alerts
  • Identity Guard found 35 alerts in total
  • 15 unique dark web alerts
  • IDShield found 24 alerts in total and,
  • 8 unique dark web alerts
Threat Resolution
Only the most expensive Ultra plan offers white glove support
Excellent customer service
Theft Insurance Per Adult
$1 million total theft insurance on all plans
$1 million total theft insurance on all plans
Customer Support
  • Great US-based customer support but doesn’t have 24/7 hours of operation
  • Mon-Fri 8 a.m. -11 p.m. EST Sat 9 a.m. – 6 p.m.
US-based 24/7 support
Additional Services
  • “Safe browsing tool”
  • Password manager
  • VPN
  • Antivirus software (with 15 device licenses)
  • Password manager
  • Reputation management tool
Cost
Identity Guard is great if you want the cheapest plan, but the best plan – Ultra is expensive
More expensive than Aura with less protection
Renewal Price Increased After 1st Year?
No. You lock in the price for life
No
Promo Code

Identity Guard Pros

Their monitoring is really comprehensive, but only  if you’re on the Ultra plan. And, like Aura, they came back with the most alerts in our tests – 35 total, including 15 unique dark web alerts. 

Also, it only took 2 minutes for alerts to pop up. That’s quite fantastic! 

Customer support is US-based, savvy and quick to answer. Their support staff are well-versed in identity theft matters and have mostly got a minimum of 7 years’ experience in the industry.

Identity Guard Cons

You have to pay for the truly worthwhile protection – which is only with the Ultra plan. 

With the Value plan, you only get $1 million insurance, access to the customer care team, risk management, data breach, dark web, and high risk transaction monitoring, plus the safe browsing tool. 

The next tier, the Total plan, only adds bank account monitoring, the 1-bureau credit score and 3-bureau monitoring, for more money. 

Ultra offers all of the above, plus white glove resolution concierge support, social media insights report, credit and debit card monitoring, 401(k) and investment account monitoring, criminal and sex offender registry monitoring, USPS address change monitoring, and home title monitoring. However, at a hugely inflated price.

Even though customer support is good, their hours are not helpful if you need them after hours: Mon-Fri from 8 a.m. – 11 p.m. EST, and Saturdays from 9 a.m. – 6 p.m. EST. Closed on Sundays.

They have no couples plan, only a family plan (with another hefty markup in price). 

Across all plans, the maximum identity theft insurance is $1 million regardless of how many members are registered in the plan.

In the Family plan, you can have 5 adults and an unlimited number of children covered. However, all the children have to live at the same address as the primary member – which isn’t always practical if you want to add children living with a divorced partner, or a kid away at college.

Also, Identity Guard discounts change erratically. Keep an eye out on their website (it’s currently at 16% off across all plans). Our discount link will give you 33% off and it’s great that the price you pay today remains the same for life as well. 

You also get a 60-day money-back guarantee if you go for the annual plans.

Identity Guard Pricing, Free Trial, and Promo Codes

Plan Type
Annual Billing
Monthly Billing
Individual Value
$86.40 /year
$7.20 /month
Individual Total
$191.88 /year
$15.99 /month
Individual Ultra
$287.88 /year
$23.99 /month
Family Value
$143.88 /year
$11.99 /month
Family Total
$287.88 /year
$23.99 /month
Family Ultra
$383.88 /year
$31.99 /month

IdentityForce

IdentityForce is a reasonably solid option if you want to be covered for identity theft protection service, but don’t want much else.

IdentityForce monitors residential address changes, court records, dark web activity, sex offenders moving into your neighborhood, payday loans, and your bank and credit card accounts.

Identity Force vs. IDShield: Head-to-Head Comparison

IdentityForce
IDShield
Overall Score
4/5
3.5/5
Monitoring & Alerts
  • IdentityForce found 19 alerts in all, and
  • 7 dark web alerts
  • IDShield found 24 alerts in total
  • 8 unique dark web alerts
Threat Resolution
Concierge fraud resolution service
Excellent customer service
Theft Insurance Per Adult
$1 million in coverage for lost funds and expenses, separately
$1 million total theft insurance on all plans
Customer Support
  • US-based
  • 8 a.m. – 5.30 p.m. (EST) 7 days a week
US-based 24/7 support
Additional Services
  • VPN only
  • Childwatch with a family plan
  • VPN
  • Antivirus software (with 15 device licenses)
  • Password manager
  • Reputation management tool
Cost
Excellent monitoring for a budget-friendly service
More expensive than Aura with less protection
Renewal Price Increased After 1st Year?
No. You lock in the price for life
No
Promo Code

IdentityForce Pros

IdentityForce offers a decent array of monitoring, covering most of the basics.

In our tests, monitoring was surprisingly quick – taking less than one minute! The results provided 19 dark web alerts and 7 unique dark web alerts.

For parents, the Childwatch protection service is added and nice to have! Single parents can purchase it at $2.75 a month. Childwatch does child credit monitoring, social media monitoring (checking for things like harassment and cyberbullying), and full identity monitoring.

IdentityForce Cons

IdentityForce’s customer service agents are only there for you between 8 a.m. and 5:30 p.m. (EST) every day, including weekends. But what if you need to handle a problem urgently outside of office hours? Well, you can’t.

Home title, 401(k), and investment monitoring is not offered, and these are crucial for many folks. 

It doesn’t offer strong extras. Their VPN leaves a lot to be desired, for example.  

Also, there is no plan for couples, meaning that you have to buy an additional individual plan for your spouse. This makes things a lot less cost-effective.

By the way, take a look at their website – The tier pricing is somewhat confusing. I had to call in so that customer service could explain them. 

I also discovered that the website jumps to a more expensive individual plan if you navigate away from the plans and pricing plan page and want to return to it. Odd, right?

You also can’t see their Family plan on the website – you have to call for pricing. It’s strange, and I can only assume this is because it fluctuates. 

I have managed to provide you with the full range of prices below.

IdentityForce Pricing, Free Trial, and Promo Codes

Plan Type
Annual Billing
Monthly Billing
Ultra Secure
$179.50 /year
$17.95 /month
UltraSecure
$239.40 /year
$19.95 /month
UltraSecure + Credit Monitoring
$239.50 /year
$23.95 /month
Get 25% NOW

IdentityForce currently has a 30-day free trial period. If you choose to not use our promo code, they’re offering their own 18% off promo code.

Costco Complete ID

Complete ID is a very basic identity theft protection service, and is only for Costco members. 

The service covers the following: dark web surveillance, Social Security number monitoring, neighborhood watch, criminal record monitoring, alternative loan monitoring, child monitoring,  financial account takeover services, and mail change alerts. 

Costco Complete ID vs. IDShield: Head-to-Head Comparison

Complete ID
IDShield
Overall Score
3/5
3.5/5
Monitoring & Alerts
  • After many days CompleteID came back with 27 alerts in total, but
  • No unique dark web alerts
  • IDShield found 24 alerts in total and,
  • 8 unique dark web alerts
Threat Resolution
Reasonable customer service
Excellent customer service
Theft Insurance Per Adult
$1 million for expenses and lost funds combined
$1 million total theft insurance on all plans
Customer Support
US-based 24/7 support
US-based 24/7 support
Additional Services
  • VPN
  • ‘Safe Browser’
  • Password manager
  • VPN
  • Antivirus software (with 15 device licenses)
  • Password manager
  • Reputation management tool
Cost
Expensive if you take into regard you need to buy Costco membership first
More expensive than Aura with less protection
Renewal Price Increased After 1st Year?
No, not currently, but you need to watch it
No

Costco Complete ID Pros

Unless you’re already a Costco member and get any benefits associated with membership, there really aren’t many Complete ID pros.

One aspect worth noting though, is their sex offender and criminal registry monitoring or neighborhood watch monitoring. It’s astonishingly detailed and thorough. They notify you about any known criminals in your area and their details. 

Costco Complete ID Cons

Unfortunately, Complete ID doesn’t cover 401(k), investments, and home title monitoring. They also don’t cover USPS address change monitoring or offer any type of social media monitoring.

Subscription to Complete ID actually costs you an extra $60 per year (for Business/Gold Star members) or $120 a year (for Executive members) because you need to factor in the cost of being a Costco member to access this.

Complete ID covers only two adults and 5 children on their Family plan. Most other services cover far more children at least, and many even cover unlimited children..

Reimbursement for legal fees cannot exceed $125 an hour under their theft insurance cover. 

Furthermore, each adult only gets $500,000 identity theft insurance each on the couple’s or family plan.

Also, there are no promo codes, discounts or free trials.

Costco Complete ID Pricing, Free Trial, and Promo Codes

Plan Type
Executive Members
Gold Star Members
Individual Value
$8.99 /month
$13.99 /month
One Adult + Children
$11.98 /month
$17.98 /month
Two Adults
$15.99 /month
$25.99 /month
Two Adults + Children
$18.99 /month
$29.99 /month

Complete ID currently has no free trial, no promo code, and no discounts.